Newsletter Subscribe
Enter your email address below and subscribe to our newsletter
[forminator_form id="25163"]

wtvbamreuters+1reutersAlphabet unit Google on Wednesday urged Europe's top court to dismiss EU antitrust regulators' appeal against a lower court ruling that scrapped a €1.49 billion ($1.7 billion) fine, in a case that tests the European Commission's ability to enforce competition rules against major U.S. tech companies.wtvbam+2
The case before the Court of Justice of the European Union concerns a fine originally imposed by the European Commission in March 2019 for what regulators said was Google's abuse of its dominant position in the online search advertising market through its AdSense for Search platform. The Commission found that Google had imposed restrictive clauses in contracts with third-party websites that prevented rivals from placing search advertisements on those sites.goodwinlaw+2
The EU's General Court annulled the fine in September 2024, finding that while Google held a dominant market position, the Commission had committed errors in assessing the duration and impact of the restrictive clauses and had not properly demonstrated that Google's contracts foreclosed competition or harmed consumers. The Commission subsequently appealed to the Court of Justice, Europe's highest court, in case C-826/24 P.curia.europa+2
The hearing comes just weeks after the same court dealt Google a blow on July 2, dismissing the company's appeal against a separate, record €4.1 billion antitrust fine related to its Android mobile operating system. That ruling, which marked the end of an eight-year legal battle, confirmed that Google used Android to shut out competitors.reuters+2
Google's three EU antitrust cases have collectively resulted in more than €8 billion in fines. The AdSense appeal represents the Commission's only loss among the trio, and its outcome will shape the bloc's enforcement credibility in digital markets.wikipedia
The General Court's 2024 ruling set a high bar for proving anticompetitive conduct under EU law, requiring the Commission to substantiate claims about foreclosure effects rather than relying on the existence of restrictive contract terms alone. Under the newer Digital Markets Act, the Commission would no longer need to prove such effects for designated gatekeepers like Google. A loss at the Court of Justice would nonetheless mark a rare and lasting defeat for the Commission's traditional antitrust enforcement toolkit.stibbe